Hero goes his own way

The trek to the head of the Dudhsagar Falls was supposed to have been the highlight of our trip. We were taking a four-day break at a place called ‘Off the Grid’, a house belonging to a couple called John Pollard and Sylvia Kerkar, situated near Castlerock in the Western Ghats. Everything we had heard and read about it before we left Goa made us feel it would be the perfect place for us and the dogs — the kind of place we had been hunting for ever since we got to Goa, but had so far failed to locate.

John and Sylvia’s house is in a bowl ringed with densely-forested hills.

(You can click on the photographs to view them larger.)

Off the Grid had lived up to its promise. It’s a wonderful house, built to sustainable principles, in the perfect of places. It’s in a bowl surrounded by hills, with a sparklingly clear stream running along one boundary of the property. The place is literally off the grid – there is neither electricity nor telephone connectivity. Solar lights are charged during the day, and provide ample but not overly powerful illumination at night. The house itself is built on two levels, with delightful little innovations such as a stone platform bed in the main bedroom, left hollowed for storage under it, and canvas tents in place of cemented walls on the first floor.

Small channels have been diverted from waterways to run through the grounds of the house, which are then used to irrigate beds where John and Sylvia grow lettuce, tomatoes, tambdi bhaji and various other vegetables and fruits. Some rivulets water the fecund Mallika mango trees that cluster close to the house. One channel perpetually replenishes a small tank right next to the house, in which stepped borders allow you to loll about in waist-deep water.

For the dogs, there was ample room to frolic, and a stream to play in or drink from. For us, a tranquil place to do nothing for a few days. With Shankar and Kalpana to look after our every need. It was perfect.

We arrived on Sunday, exhausted after a late-night party the day before, and spent the first day simply relaxing, our only effort being an evening stroll down to the stream. John and Sylvia have created a natural dam with rocks across the stream at one point, which forms a knee-deep pool upstream of itself. On both sides of the dam, little black fish congregate in the limpid water. Sungta and Soulkadi chased these, Jaya sat down in the shallows, while the rest of the dogs splashed around or explored the banks. Knowing Hero’s proclivities, I held on to his leash most of the time, but the rest were restrained only by our commands. At one point, Chipku led an attempted break back towards the house, but it took only a strident admonition from one of us to keep the escapees in check.

Jaya sits in the stream, while Chipku and Hero explore the area.

Sungta and Soulkadi play in the water as Bhaloo daintily tiptoes across the dam of rocks.

On the next day, we went with Shankar for a long hike through the woods and hills above the house. It was strenuous to our unaccustomed bodies, but the beauty of the area made it worthwhile. After a little tussle, Anjali agreed reluctantly to my suggestion that we let the dogs go. Again, Hero was the one dog whom I held on to. The others responded as I had expected they would. The unfamiliarity of the area, and perhaps its threatening smells — after all, leopards prowl in these jungles, as do various other smaller predators such as wild dogs and hyenas — kept them a little nervous. So while they hit the trail with enthusiasm and energy, they never drifted far from us. The pups, in particular, stayed close, stopping for us to catch up every time their exploratory instincts pulled them ahead of the peloton.

On the hike in the woods and fields around the house.

Shankar and the dogs blaze a scary trail.

So it was that we left for the Dudhsagar trek on day three with great expectations. The drive there was, for lack of a better word, invigorating. The large proportion of the ride was on dirt tracks, and in extended stretches, you couldn’t even call it that. At times, we were taking slopes in first gear with the car’s nose in the air, seemingly vertically above us. At others, we were heading down equally sharp slopes where the car’s weight was sending the scree skittering downhill, making me wonder whether we would be able to make it back up when we returned.

The Scorpio’s original tyres had worn down over the years, and we had bought two new tyres and retreaded two others just before we left. The Dudhsagar journey made us very grateful we had — the old tyres would never have taken the beating.

Eventually, we reached a clearing where we parked the car and commenced the trek on foot. The path that led into the forest was overhung with brambly branches, and would have served well as a model for a magical entrance to the enchanted Fangorn Forest in ‘Lord of the Rings’.

This trek was much tougher than the previous day’s. The jungle was much thicker, and the path quite evidently less-travelled. In many places, you wouldn’t really have been able to tell there was a path at all, except for the now-faded white arrows that had been painted on rocks and trees every now and again. Of course, Shankar seemed to know every branch and stone, and led us at a brisk pace that had not just Anjali and me, but the dogs panting as well. As with previous days, Hero was restrained on his leash, while the other dogs were allowed to walk unharnessed, with their leashes trailing behind them.

The path to the top of the Dudhsagar falls.

A bamboo bridge across a stream in the forest – the dogs were wary of its ricketiness, and preferred wading across.

The last descent to the falls was very steep, and I knew we would really be tried when we came back up that way. I was holding on to Hero’s leash, and he was remarkably conscious of my needs. No doubt he wanted to rush down the slope the way the other dogs were going, but I only needed to give the leash a gentle yank now and then to remind him that he had to go down at my pace.

The path came out onto a largish flat rock, from which we would have to hop from one rock to another to get out to the actual head of the falls. This had to be done very carefully. Not only were some of the rocks large enough for us to need to use handholds as we went down them, the gaps between rocks was often large enough that we had to make measured jumps. Also, though the summer had rendered the stream of water quite sparse, there were still enough places where the water gushed through or collected and kept the rocks slippery.

On the rocks at the top of the falls – Hero takes a swim in a pool.

I told Anjali I couldn’t hold on to Hero’s leash here. She was again uncomfortable with the idea, but she saw my point. The terrain here could cause me serious injury if Hero were to jump when I was unprepared, or even if he were to just pull me off-balance. Even having the leashes trailing behind them, I felt, was a danger to the dogs. If a leash were to get caught on an outcrop or stuck in a crevice when a dog jumped from one rock to another, it could do them bodily harm. So, for the last stretch, near the head of the falls where the going was trickiest, we took the leashes off the dogs’ collars.

The dogs follow Shankar down towards the edge of the cliff.

The six dogs followed the nimble-footed Shankar out to the edge of the cliff while Anjali and I followed more slowly. Anjali went out to the edge, but I realised that I have something of a fear of heights and hung back, unnerved by the steepness and depth of the fall. Even from where I was, some metres back from the edge, the view was stupendous. There were deep green forests everywhere I looked, far across the void. Way down below, the Konkan Railway tracks snaked out from a tunnel and around the hillside to a point far below where we were, before continuing on their way towards the little station of Castlerock.

The view from the top, with the train tracks visible far below.

While we stood breathing in the view, Hero suddenly decided he wanted a closer look. Heedless of our stern warnings, he bounded off down a steep rock-and-brush slope just to the right of the falls, circling back onto a ledge some distance below the edge where Anjali and Shankar were standing with the other dogs. Though we were all a little concerned, the two of them could see him sitting on the rock shelf below, evidently quite happy with the location he had reached. Anjali even took a couple of photographs of him in his majestic pose, monarch of all he surveyed. It seemed likely that after he had had his fill of sitting there, he would return to where we were, so we let him be. Once in a while, we would yell for him to come back up, more as a reminder to him that we were up there than anything else.

Our last glimpse of Hero – sitting on a ledge, monarch of all he surveys.

After a little while, though, Shankar reported that Hero had left his perch and taken off into the forests that covered the slopes to the right of the falls. Though that was more worrying, we still felt that he wouldn’t go too far. We kept yelling his name, but the minutes passed and there was no sign of him. When it had been close to half an hour, we felt we needed to do something else. After a little confused discussion — we had begun to grow increasingly unsure of the situation, but neither of us was willing to put our dread into words — Shankar and I plus four of the dogs headed back into the woods the way we’d come, while Anjali waited on the rocks with Jaya.

As we walked back along the path, I kept yelling Hero’s name out loudly. Behind me, the sound gradually fading as we moved away from her position, I could hear Anjali doing the same. What was in our minds was that perhaps Hero had found his way back through the jungle to the path, or was somewhere nearby. Barring the rushing sound of water when one was close to the river bed, the jungle was quite still and the sound of our shouts would carry quite a long distance. But all the way back to the car, there was no sign of Hero. When we emerged into the clearing, I half-hoped to see him waiting for us near the car, but he wasn’t.

I debated what to do next — we hadn’t quite sorted that out when Shankar and I had left. The feeling that Hero would turn up had still been so strong that a worst-case scenario had not been contemplated. Finally, I told Shankar I would wait with the dogs at the car, and he should go and get Anjali.

He hesitated when I suggested this.

“Madam nahin aayegi,” he said doubtfully.

I understood his reluctance — how could he persuade Anjali to leave without Hero? But we had not amply thought the plan through earlier, and I could now see no other option. The alternative was for me to go back, and for him to wait with the other dogs, which made less sense. So I picked the lesser of the two evils, and told him that she would have to come back, so he’d have to go get her.

Without the sheltering canopy of the jungle, it was blisteringly hot, and the dogs were panting desperately in the oven-like confines of the black Scorpio. I backed the car into an area where there was a little shade, but it was still very uncomfortable. The rucksack in which we had carried the dogs’ water bowls had been left behind with Anjali, as that also had chewies and other treats that could have been used to entice Hero if he returned. I rummaged around the car, but there was nothing I could give the dogs water in. Finally, I found a funnel, and used a piece of cloth to plug its opening. I filled this with water from a can we had in the car, and offered it to each of the thirsty dogs in turn.

The wait was long – more than a couple of hours — and when I heard the sound from afar of Anjali shouting Hero’s name as she and Shankar wound their way back, I knew that her vigil had been unsuccessful too.

We drove back home, unable to talk about the situation.

“Keep honking the horn,” Anjali told me as we left. “If he hears it, he might follow.”

Though the geography of the area told me this was entirely pointless, I did as she said. On the way, we spoke to any villagers we met – Shankar describing our predicament to them as passionately as if Hero was his own – and told them to keep an eye out for Hero.

Back at the house, we fed the dogs and tried to eat a little ourselves, though Anjali found herself unable to. As soon as we could, we headed straight back to the clearing.

This time, Anjali waited in the car, while Shankar and I trekked into the jungle. It was late evening, and gathering clouds had made the evening gloomier than it would have been naturally. How different everything seemed from the way it had that morning. The entrance into the jungle, which had looked so cool and inviting earlier, was now the maw of a monster, capable of swallowing whatever entered into it and spitting out only bones.

Shankar and I made good speed — he must have been conscious of the fact that we needed to get to the falls and out again before darkness fell. By the time we got to therocky riverbed, it was already threateningly dark. By now, my hopes had sunk, so I was not really surprised when there was no Hero waiting for us at the place where we’d last seen him.

The trek back was the most painful. Despair and loss — added to a level of physical effort which I have got long unused to — had deprived me of all strength and energy. By the time we had got to the top of the steep slope up from the falls, my breath was coming in deep painful gasps, and my legs were shaking completely out of my control. Yet we had to hurry back, and I staggered drunkenly after Shankar. The undergrowth clawed at my feet, and my eyes seemed to lose focus, making me stumble at every other step. I was still yelling “Hero, Hero” but by now it must have sounded like the screaming of a banshee. Perhaps, I thought, somewhere Hero too was yowling plaintively for us, unaware that his cries would only bring him something that was too big even for his strong body and stout heart to handle.

As we crossed the last stream over the bamboo bridge that had been so enchanting when we had reached it that morning, the first few drops of rain started splattering on us. The path was all uphill from here, through dense forest, and it was now dark enough for us to have to use our torches. The jungle was already beginning to come to life, and I could hear the plops and swishes of unseen creatures getting out of our way on the jungle floor.

Up above, the rain had become more insistent. The canopy was thick, so we experienced it more as the sound of the drops on the treetops than as wetness down below. But when we emerged into the clearing, the full force of the storm hit us, a wet and windy embodiment of the realisation that this was it, that we would now have to leave Hero at the mercy of the elements. I was thankful for the rain, as I could let the tears flow and mix with the wetness on my face. I suspect that Shankar too was crying as we left.

The storm raged and the rain poured down as we drove through the darkness, lightning strikes illuminating the savage landscape. Mud churned under our wheels and there were a few places where it seemed impossible that the Scorpio would pull through. The night had brought something as terrible and terrifying as the day had been bright and sunny, and we knew how it wiped out almost any likelihood of Hero finding his way back out of the jungle.

Over the next two days, we went back to the area again and again. We scoured all the neighbouring villages and left word with everyone we could, right down to the shopkeepers in Castlerock town, some fifteen kilometres away. The final departure, as we left for Goa, was wrenching. We were leaving a part of ourselves, of our shared past, behind, and the pain of doing so was immense.

That was four days ago. Since then, Anjali has already been back to Dudhsagar with a trekking enthusiast who knows the area. They hunted in the terrain at the base of the falls, on the outside chance that Hero had climbed all the way down. They left pamphlets showing a photo of Hero with everyone they could find. Information has been spread amongst friends and forest officials, wildlife groups and trekking clubs, villagers and veterinarians.

We know, though, that it will be almost miraculous if we are to find Hero now or any time in the future. Even if he were to have survived the jungle, the geographic scope of his escapade is just so vast. He could have come out just about anywhere in a huge area.

By now, Anjali and I are reconciled with the idea that we will almost certainly never see him again. Not that it stops us hoping, but it helps us cope. We’ve had friends and family to give us strength and comfort. We’ve had words of support and advice from total strangers.

We’ve also, of course, had the occasional person who’s hinted or wondered aloud at why we would take dogs into such potentially dangerous situations. Sometimes, these words have clearly held the underlying judgement that given our foolhardiness, it’s only fitting that we have suffered this trauma. This is usually from people who don’t know us or our dogs too well.

We are, thankfully, too confident of our motives and our beliefs for such attitudes to upset us. Everyone decides in their own lives where the line between experience and adventure and needless risk lies, and we have not drawn our line without forethought. We have seen over and over how exciting our travelling is for our dogs, and that makes it worth it. Of course, there is risk in such a choice, but we do everything we can to minimise it. That we – or our dogs – have to face the consequences of that risk is something we have always accepted, and finally had to bear, after many years of dong what we all loved doing.

As to Hero’s possible fate, Anjali and I have painted so many different scenarios for ourselves. Of course, the most likely one is that he met his end at the teeth and claws of predators too large or too numerous for him to fight off. There are, of course, certain other possibilities that we can’t bring ourselves to speak about — that he might have ended his days lying in a crevasse, hurt and bleeding. Or that he landed up, out of hunger and desperation, with someone who is keeping him like we have seen so many dogs kept, chained forever, half-starved and unloved.

But there are also more positive alternatives. The most promising one, in our eyes, is that Hero found his way out of the jungle, and has gone off to forge a new life for himself, at which we are confident he will succeed. Over the last few years, as he has grown in size and acumen, Hero has increasingly taken to spending periods away from home, sometimes for weeks at a time. When we have seen him on the streets during these forays, we have seen that he has blended in with, or even taken over, some pack which he then lords over. He is particularly fond of puppies and we have sometimes seen him sitting regally on the street while other strays’ pups gambol around him.

So in the perfect case, we see Hero — like Jack London’s Buck — taking over as the alpha male of some pack of feral dogs, and leading them to lives of glory. With Hero, it’s not an impossible dream.

41 responses to “Hero goes his own way

  1. Lucano Alvares

    What a heart-rending account. We feel your loss and offer you our deepest sympathies.

  2. salil chaturvedi

    What memories, what a life! He was my lucky mascot, and whenever I was asked to provide a picture of mine by a publisher or a magazine, it would be the one with Hero, the one that is still on my blog and will always be. Won’t forget him going after Monika’s derriere (Hero had good taste) all through our 2,000 km trip from Goa to Delhi, and the punches he received from me when he growled if I shifted in bed at night, while sharing it with him. Truly a Hero.

  3. Melinda Powell

    I empathise with you and Anjali.I like the way you put your emotions and feelings on paper — a catharsis of some kind. You did your best.
    Cherish all the good times and good memories of Hero. I know what you feel–it is like a part of you is gone.

  4. This was heartbreaking to read, Annie. I’m so sorry for your loss and I still hope you will hear some news of Hero soon.

  5. ananya ,taran

    we felt sad reading your essay and seeing the pictures of hero
    we hope to see him again

  6. Your account is very moving. But I still feel that he went because he wanted to and wherever he is, he is happy and doing his own thing. So let us be happy also.

  7. So sorry to hear this. I know how much Hero meant to your family! I do hope he turns up some day with lots of adventures to tell! L x

  8. Thank you for all the responses, everyone. Your sympathy and good wishes count for a lot with us.

  9. Annie, I’m truly devastated to hear about Hero disappearing – can’t imagine what Anjali and you must be feeling. But I am convinced he is okay wherever he is. You guys take care. Much love.

  10. Dear Annie & Anjali,
    As an animal lover, I feel your pain and loss. At various points in our lives, we go through similar pain. In my early childhood, we rescued an injured stray bird from the road and became so attached to her that when we found her dead after some years with us, we wept and laid her to rest in a tin of the chocolate candies she loved so much. Later, it was gut-wrenching for us to leave Trusty our Alsation behind, albeit with good friends, when we left Dar-es-Salaam for good because at that time ships on the India-run did not allow kennels. More recently, we cried bucketfuls as we laid Ziggy our 12 year-old Doberman-Boxer to rest after she died from complications after being hit by a vehicle. Just as she used to dutifully came to greet us at the gate even when we returned after a late party, she waited to meet us till we returned from a trip to the States, before breathing her last.
    The dilemma of allowing animals (or for that matter children) that are dear to you, to run free, is perennial. Keep them ‘safe’ by restraint, consequently curbing their freedom and creativity or allow them the space (within bounds of course) to discover and achieve for themselves, with all the inherent risks that freedom entails? With our children, Fatima & I incline towards the latter and leave the protection in His hands.
    I enjoyed reading your essay immensely.
    Xavier
    PS Seven months after Ziggy moved on, we have a home-grown replacement for her. Though not related, Ziggy Jr shares her long snout and affable nature.

    • Thanks, Xavier, for your heartfelt response. It’s a big help that we have so many friends who understand exactly what it’s like for us, and empathise with us.

  11. Kevin Saldanha

    My thoughts are with both of you as well as your four-legged family, including Hero. Thank you for sharing this detailed account of what happened that fateful day and know that there was nothing else better than allowing him his freedom to enjoy the day.

  12. Jose Lourenco

    This is the way to live. To love and be loved by those around you. And when the call comes, to seek the wild. When the trapeze artist falls and is mortally wounded in Thus Spake Zarathustra, Nietzsche’s protagonist says: “You have made danger your calling; there is nothing contemptible in that. ”

    Hero has chosen to live dangerously, and in that he is true to his name. And an inspiration and call to us too.

  13. Dear anjali &annie,
    Iam really sorry to hear about heros loss.I got to really know hero on our ahmedabhad trip how gently he rested his head on my lap making himself more and more comfortable to get the cool Ac he was really baby like then.I do hope wherever he is he is happyand loved as much.

    • Yes, Suraya, it was difficult for those who got to know him not to love him. That trip was such fun.

  14. Dear Anjali and Annie,

    Sincerely hope that your narration has a happy ending and Hero returns back miraculously. Else, hope that he is safe and sound and starting a new chapter of his heroic life. Strength and love to both of you.

    Take care, Gani, Beni, Trusha, Trikaya and Feni

  15. amita kanekar

    A beautiful and heart-rending account, Annie. I can’t imagine your and Anjali’s pain, but, as you have pointed out, Hero was an independent-minded hero, so there is some genuine chance that he will survive, even thrive. Really hope so.

  16. a hero stands alone. new paths follow one. and are there for us to tread. whatever is written. whatever is read. has heroes that have led. blessed is the time in their amid we spend. the universe has its own divine plan. and as the name goes his next mission marvel will have magic and will be merry in the end. a hero stands alone.
    annie anjali thank you

  17. Reuben Coutinho

    greetings to Mr. & Mrs. SenGupta,
    i just perused through your article ‘dogs bless his soul’ and i must say that it was so very well written; beautiful & emotive; i had a lot of hope like you’ll too that we would find Hero last week but well, things do’nt always go the way we want them too; fate ai’nt in our hands?-our prayers are’nt always answered no matter how right we think we are– to keep things short, i just wanna say that i’m truly sorry for the loss of your dear pet and may you both get over the unfortunate circumstance very soon. i do believe in miracles so, the story ai’nt over yet i feel; keep the faith and carry on with hope in your hearts and a prayer on your lips.
    i’m sorry once again, let’s move on…
    with much regard and heartfelt wishes to you both,
    Reuben Coutinho.

  18. Sorry to hear about your loss Annie! Also sad to know that you are leaving Goa..Stay safe and in your own way, as you have always been!
    My regards to both of you!
    Kaustubh

  19. Hi – I mustered enough courage to read the piece today morning. Wish it was just another of your writings and I could have finished off with ‘beautifully written, lovely pictures’ kind of comments. Like my Mini, Hero was always the truant child and I guess all the more loveable because of that. A big big hug to both of you…wish there was some way the pain could be lessened.

  20. Dear Annie, Anjali,
    Just got back yesterday, so have been out of touch. Very sorry to hear about Hero. I just hope he’s happy wherever he is. I still think you may have not seen or heard the last of him!

  21. Mathala Juliet

    I love Hero 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s